‘Parallel Market Unstoppable’

“IT’S too late to stop the parallel market,” said Naison Chikara as he struggled to stuff a bundle of Zimbabwean dollars into his pocket.

 

Chikara’s statement might sound too optimistic but it reflects the attitude among those that trade foreign currency on the black market on the streets of Harare.

These traders have every reason to believe that their “industry” is here to stay even though the monetary authorities thought they had fixed the black market by liberalising the foreign currency exchange three months ago.

“We will continue to push the rate until they (central bank) realise that it’s unsustainable,” Chikara said.

As the rate continues to gallop there is now a belief in the market that this liberalisation might not last after all.

An analysis of the operations of the central bank since 2003 lends credence to this belief that the market is far from stabilising.

So many foreign exchange policies have been tried but all of them have failed. Some have been withdrawn before they could be implemented. To track this policy changes one has to look a governor Gideon Gono’s tenure in office since December 2003.

His tenure at the central bank has been characterised by uncertainty on the foreign currency market.

With each monetary policy, the market has come to expect a raft of new foreign currency policies.

Gono set up semi-weekly RBZ-controlled auctions soon after assuming office.

These auctions, he said, would determine
the official exchange rate which had been pegged at $824 to the US dollar in February 2003.

The rate quickly moved to $4 196 to the greenback on January 12 to end the year at $5 730 to the US dollar through the auctions, slightly trailing the parallel market which ended the year at $6 000 for the US dollar.

The year 2005 was to be an entirely different year as the Zimbabwe dollar would tumble heavily against major currencies. The rate moved to $6 200 in March and then $9 000 for the US dollar in May. The parallel market surged to $14 000 and then to $20 000 against the US dollar in respective periods. In the same year, Gono devalued the dollar to $10 800 to the greenback on July 18.

He then changed it to $17 600 on July 25, before pushing it down to $24 500 on August 25. The dollar was to be devalued three more times in 2005, starting in September when it moved to $26 003, to $60 000 in November and finally to $84 588 in December.

That did not seem to work as the parallel market continued to race ahead. On July 18 it was $25 000, then $45 000 on August 25, $75 000 in September, $90 000 in November and closing the year at $96 000 in December.

Gono then discontinued the RBZ currency auctions in November 2005 and announced that market factors would determine the exchange rate.

Gono at that time said there were some players who were abusing and tinkering with the auction floor systems. But even he had to accept that the auctions had been quite successful, despite removing them.

The foreign currency generated in the first quarter of 2004 using the auction system surpassed the total inflows registered in 2003. Over US$192,9 million was raised through the first quarter auctions.

On January 3, 2006, the dollar was again devalued to $85 158: US$1. It moved to $99 201,58 on January 24 and then to $101 195,54 on April 28 where it was to stay until July 31.

The parallel market continued to gallop to reach $550 000 on July 27. After the revaluation exercise on August 1, 2006, in which three zeros were lopped off the dollar, the exchange rate was moved to $250 to the US dollar where it was to stay until August 2007.

However, a special rate of $15 000 was applied for miners, farmers, NGOs, embassies and Zimbabweans living abroad. Meanwhile the parallel market continued to race further ahead of the official market.

It rose from $550 to the US dollar on August 1, 2006 to $1 500 on October 12. It then shot up to $3 200 on January 11, 2007 and on April 1, it stood at $30 000. But it was not until June 2007 that the real madness began on the parallel market, coinciding with government’s price blitz. On June 3 US$1 was worth $55 000. Twenty days later, it took $400 000 to buy the greenback.

The dollar was devalued again in September 2007 to $30 000 against the US dollar. On April 30 Gono decided to do what the market had been advising him for four years and let the dollar float. Thrilled at the prospect of eliminating the parallel market, Gono’s optimism was unfettered.

“Given the centrality of foreign exchange in the economy,” Gono said, “its pricing has to take into account the need to incentivise all its generators to remain viable, whilst at the same time minimizing the intended adverse consequences on the vulnerable segments of society.”

He introduced the Priority Focused Foreign Currency Twinning Arrangement, which allowed the exchange rate to float at market forces.

The interbank rate started on a high, eclipsing the parallel market in the first week as it paid between $165 million and $185 million against parallel market dealer rates of $120 million for the US dollar.

For the first time since Gono removed the auction system, it appeared the public’s confidence in the official system was slowly returning. Then the tables started turning. The parallel market is back on top. There are now fears that Gono might change policies again. Gono did not mention a time frame for how long the current situation would prevail. He simply said the pricing framework would respond to “contemporary developments” in the economy. Six weeks later, the interbank rate is now $1 billion while the parallel market was paying $1,1 billion for the US dollar.

There are no signs of the rate stabilising and economists contend that the rate could very well be above $2 billion by June 27. Now the question on everyone’s mind is whether Gono’s move to liberalise the exchange rate wasn’t “too little, too late”.

University of Zimbabwe business lecturer, Professor Anthony Hawkins, said Gono had failed to respond to the crisis in time. “He took too long to address the crisis,” Hawkins said.

“The crisis has reached unmanageable levels now. While giving him credit for making the move to liberalise the exchange rate since it was a move towards rationality, his decision should have been made a long time ago.”

Another Harare economist, John Robertson said the crisis was now frightening and that at the present rate of devaluation, the Zimbabwean dollar would trade with the US dollar above $2 billion by the end of the month.

The new interbank rate has resulted in rising prices across the board; some have even called it a legalisation of the parallel market.

The rising prices have attracted the anger of Mugabe who said it was a regime change agenda. Five cabinet ministers met a month ago and blasted the interbank rate for resulting in huge surges in prices and inflation.

Hawkins said all this, coupled with the huge increases in money supply growth, would never result in a stabilisation of the Zimbabwean dollar.

“Unless he stops printing money, we will not get anywhere,” Hawkins said.

“Whether he will remove the interbank rate, I can’t say. Only time will tell.”

Gono is still insisting that the interbank market is there to stay. In an interview last week Gono said he was not planning any policy changes anytime soon.

“There is no going back on the new policy. Its there to stay. We are however aware that there are some people who are trying to manipulate the system. We will deal with that soon,” said Gono.

By Bernard Mpofu/Kuda Chikwanda

Top