HomeOpinionRisk of miscalculation in Korean peninsular real

Risk of miscalculation in Korean peninsular real

The joint US/South Korean military exercises known as “Key Resolve” and “Foal Eagle” are underway, and so far the heavens have not fallen.

Opinion by Gwynne Dyer

The American forces have not launched an unprovoked assault on North Korea, despite the strident claims of the media in the North Korean capital of Pyongyang that the exercises are a cover for exactly such a plan. In fact, joint exercises on this scale — they only involve 13,000 American and South Korean troops — have been held every year of the past 40, and pose no threat whatsoever to North Korea.

Neither has North Korea chosen to “defend its sovereignty,” as it recently threatened to do, by launching pre-emptive nuclear strikes against both the United States and South Korea. It could certainly do huge damage to South Korea; but despite its successful nuclear and missile tests in the past three months, it still lacks all but the most rudimentary capability to hit the United States.

Pyongyang’s nuclear test in February had twice the explosive power of the last one in 2009, but nobody believes North Korea’s claim that it has also made its bomb small enough to fit on the tip of an intercontinental ballistic missile.

Nor does the Unha-3 missile, which Pyongyang used to launch a satellite in December, have the guidance systems and re-entry technology necessary to deliver such a nuclear weapon onto an American target — which would have to be in western Alaska, since that is the limit of the rocket’s range.

There is no doubt that Kim Jong-un’s regime is feeling extremely peeved about the international response to its weapon and missile tests — a response which has included tighter United Nations trade sanctions that got unanimous support in the Security Council. Even North Korea’s only ally, China, voted for the sanctions.

But it’s a long way from feeling peeved to feeling suicidal. Any North Korean nuclear attack on an American target would be answered by immediate US strikes that would annihilate the military and civilian leadership in Pyongyang, obliterate its nuclear facilities, and probably destroy much else besides.

So North Korea’s threat to launch a “pre-emptive” nuclear strike against the United States, or even against South Korea, is totally implausible.

However, the young and inexperienced North Korean leader may feel the need to prove his mettle to his own military commanders by taking some more limited action against the US-South Korean exercises. That sort of thing can easily go wrong.

There is a widespread perception in South Korea that Seoul was caught off guard by North Korea’s sinking of the warship Cheonan and its artillery attacks on Yeonpyeong island in 2010.

North Korea paid no military price for either action, and South Korea’s newly elected president, Park Geun-hye, who took office only a few weeks ago, needs to show South Koreans that she is not going to let that happen again.

She probably also hopes that a promise of prompt and severe retaliation will deter North Korea from any future attacks of that sort. So she has engaged in some rhetorical escalation of her own.
She has warned North Korea that any further attacks will be met by instant retaliation that targets not only the units involved in the attack, but also North Korea’s high command.

No doubt this is only intended to deter any such North Korean attack, but in practice it means that there will be much more rapid and uncontrollable escalation if Pyongyang makes a token attack anyway.

Even a conventional war in the Korean peninsula would be hugely destructive. Just north of the “demilitarised zone” between the two countries is the largest concentration of artillery in the entire world, and the megacity of Seoul is within long artillery range of the border.

If North Korea ignored Park’s warning and made some local attack to demonstrate its displeasure, and Park then felt obliged to act on her threat to go after the North Korean leadership in Pyongyang in retaliation, things could get very ugly very fast.

So far, the U.S.-South Korean exercises have gone off smoothly, but the risk of a serious miscalculation — first in Pyongyang and then in Seoul — is real, and the exercises still have until March 25 to run.

Dyer is a London-based independent journalist.

Recent Posts

Stories you will enjoy

Recommended reading